Giving up on social bookmarking
Sunday, April 29th, 2007Now that I’m finally getting moved into a personal blog, I’m trying to decide what to do about links and bookmarking. Specifically:
I frequently end the day with 40 and sometimes as many as 100+ tabs open in Firefox. These open tabs represent things I stumbled across (whether by design or by accident) that I’m interested in following up on/reading further when and if I have time. (Have I mentioned that the net is *brutal* on philomaths?… How are we supposed to get any work done? :-)
I’ve tried a variety of systems for managing this situation, including most of the major social bookmarking sites. My favorite has been furl, because of the built-in linkrot protection, and I’ve used it on and off for a number of years.
On consideration, though, I think even furl is still a suboptimal solution for me. Reasons:
- Intermittent slow response times are frustrating (this is true of all the majors - at least from here)
- 3rd party service is not included in my regular backup process.
- Search facility is mediocre
- Linking is a powerful social gesture, especially amongst lower traffic blogs. Even if a link to a blog post is just 1 of 40 in a daily linkdump, it still represents a piece of my attention that I’ve given that person, and can act as an expression of my interest in the topic. I’d like to let the author know that I noticed and appreciated their writing - - even if just in a small way. I don’t think that being one more "add" on delicious or furl accomplishes this in quite the same way. It’s a little like the difference between sending someone a personal note, and being one of a dozen signers on a group birthday card — it’s just not quite the same thing.
So I think what I’m going to do is create a links category, modify "the loop" so that links posts are not displayed on the main blog (since I have so many of them they would overwhelm any other posts) turn off trackback pings for that section so that I don’t spam any conversations, and then create a Firefox plugin to make the recording of all open tabs a 1-click process. If I get ambitious, I may also add a spider to create my own mini-furl archive of the linked articles for linkrot protection.
I’d be interested in hearing from anybody who’s got an opinion on this, pro or con. Does my approach sound reasonable? Am I missing an essential part of the value proposition of social bookmarking sites? If so, what?
